I have come to realize that those people that say that they "wouldn't trade anything in the world" for the experience they are having raising their children, have NOT had to raise a strong willed (Type 3/1) child.
Another common expression from doting mothers is "I live for these moments!"
When I say that, what I mean is: the only thing that keeps me going through those OTHER 6 days in the week is that one afternoon when we had an almost pleasant experience together where nothing was terribly destroyed, no one cried, and possibly both of us laughed and had fun.
The term "three-nager" has a more serious meaning at our house. It isn't just a cute occasional bit of sassy attitude. Oh no, it is a way of every day living. Seriously, I thought I had another 10 years. Everything is a battle. Every idea must be approved or screamed over. If her royal highness is actually well fed and rested, there is usually just a bit of screaming and stomping; however, if she is tired or hungry ( don't ever let it be both! ), you can very well expect much pain and anguish from all parties.
It's not a party.
I kind of thought that all parents were dealing with the same sort of "grumpiness." Then we started having more friends come over more often. And we had Chloe. Obviously, most kids do not behave the same for their parents as they do for strangers, but I still see so much more attitude from Claire than almost any other child her age.
Chloe has a completely different temperament than Claire. She is happy and content to sit and play alone as long as she has been fed and isn't tired. She is so much easier to please than Claire ever was.
But Claire's bad attitude is getting to even her.
Everyone at our house is a bit on edge lately. Claire always wants to play with friends and asking her to do anything else is criminal. Peter and I fear meal and bed times with her. And Chloe has started fussing so much at night any time she hears Claire scream. Ahhhh..... blessed sounds of bedtime.
So, there's the truth of it.
We've done time outs. We've done time ins. We've had plenty of one-on-one time. We've tried talking about our feelings. We have left her to work out her tantrums on her own. We've tried giving her more "real" consequences for her actions. We still have a "reward jar" going but it is really only working when she wants it to; if she is really in a bad mood, she just doesn't care if she earns or looses cotton balls.
So tell me, oh wise world wide web, what's a girl to do?
Do I just ignore it and hope that she one day grows out of it and all that wisdom and knowledge somehow seeps in?
And if so, what am I supposed to do until then? How do I find the motivation to keep going? This daily grind is really pushing me into dust.
The balancing act of my life is flawed.
Have you seen that triangle? There are 3 parts: Clean home, Happy kids, and Mom's Sanity. You are then instructed to choose only 2.
It's really not fair.
My sanity is very closely tied to our clean home. But if that isn't enough, our "grumpy" kids wear me down SO much that it just doesn't matter if our home is clean or not. I just never win.
So give me your best shot. How to discipline (or not) your strong willed child. Or how to manage to get through this incredibly trying time in a young growing girl's life.
Sympathies also welcomed.




Being a mom can be so rough. You are amazing Melanie! Something that I've discovered that sometimes works with the sunbeam age is the idea of being a noun. Instead of saying can you clean your toys up. You could try, I need a helper who is able to be a helper. Some kids really dig being something instead of doing, I hope that makes sense. Also, I don't know but you could try the 2 choice rule for her. Tell her she gets to pick it's either A or B but she can choose which she wants. Like do you want to brush your teeth or put on your jammies. Also with bedtimes, you could try the bedtime is in 5 minutes 4 minutes etc. Strong willed kids certainly teach us patience, no? Also take all this with a grain of salt. I don't have a strong willed child but I have baby sat and taught them. Also also, you are the mommy for her. Trust your gut, it is right and it will get better. One a day at a time. You can do it Melanie.
ReplyDeleteOnly sympathies, here. For what it's worth, it sounds like you're doing an AMAZING job. I'm sure she will grow out of it. She is SUCH a sharp little whip. That's probably where a lot of it comes from... In the meantime, hang in there. You're doing a good job. It's OK to be frustrated, sometimes. Being a parent is tough.
ReplyDeleteMelanie. Thank you so much for this post!!! You literally and exactly just described my life with Liesel. It's always a little relieving to hear someone else is going through the same thing...although I would never wish THIS on anyone, but unfortunatley I don't have any tips to give - I'm on the same boat. Have tried EVERYTHING, and it only seems to be getting worse! What kind of kid refuses hugs? It doesn't matter what it is, she screams "No!" at everything now. It's so exhausting. I am so sorry you have to be going through this. I know you will find something that works. Hang in there!
ReplyDeleteOh...and in the meantime, my only advice is: make sure you take care of yourself, too. Get a break. Go out with girl friends. Ask Peter to do something with the girls while you soak in the tub or hide in the closet and eat a bowl of ice cream. :)
ReplyDeleteMelanie, you are doing amazing! No sage words of advice, I guess just a little perspective. My sister is a 3/1 and she pushed my mom to the edge pretty much her whole life, into young adulthood. At this point, she's in her 30s, she's a fantastic mom (much better than I am!), and so good at so many things. She just sort of insisted on learning things "the hard way." I guess what my parents did was teach her the gospel and continue to love her unconditionally so she knew where to turn when she decided to get it together. I'm not saying it's going to take that long for Claire, who is clearly super intelligent and talented. She may grow out of it next week, I guess I'm saying if she doesn't, it's not because you haven't stumbled on the right method. You're an amazing mom and things will work out in the end! So don't lose hope. Just keep doing your best and give yourself time to do things you enjoy to try to recover some of that sanity. I've been looking into meditation. The problem with hanging out with stubborn toddlers and preschoolers all day is my brain is pretty much bathed in negative emotions all day long. Brains tend to stay in the well-worn paths. So meditation and time out for myself is my way of giving my brain a fighting chance to feel some positive emotions.
ReplyDeleteSometimes I feel like I totally get where Lucifer was coming from when he wanted to remove free will. As a parent, I feel like I could get behind that. :) But then I remember that it wasn't just that Christ's plan was better, it's that Satan's plan straight up didn't work at all. Without choice, we would never experience consequences and we would never grow. My favorite method of disciple of Love and Logic because I feel like it aligns with gospel values of charity and choice and accountability. I love the toddler/preschooler version of that book. But it's not a magic fix. It still allows kids to make their own choices, realizing they're not always going to make the right choice. But the hope is that eventually they'll learn that kindness and obedience have much better outcomes. But, like I said, some of us like to learn the hard way. :)
Anyway, didn't mean to turn this into such a novel. In summary, you're awesome! Take care of yourself! Miss you!